TV & Film Analysis

The Saviors of American Crime

The new season of the television show American Crime is all about indulging North American fantasies about trafficking. At first glance, the show appears to be taking up the radical project of exploring the roles of border imperialism and the criminalization of migration on the coercive labor conditions experienced by farm workers in the US. If this was the entire thrust of the show, it's possible something interesting could come of it. However, the story lines centering the farm owners and laborers (that after two episodes, as of this writing, are bizarrely bifurcated by a questionable desire to "show both sides of the story" of farm labor exploitation) are interwoven with, and thus seemed designed to legitimize, hysterical fantasies of sex trafficking of white women and girls. (more…)

Uncategorized

The Role of the Documentary Filmmaker

Documentary filmmakers are not journalists: it is not our job to be "objective" - as if there even is such a thing as objectivity that one could actually practice in fields like journalism. It is not our job either to tell the whole story or give a full history, again, as if such a thing were even possible to do (especially in two hours or less of screen time). Rather, as far as I am concerned, it is a documentarian's job to tell stories that challenge established narratives, and to do so in a formal and artful manner that encourages spectators to question how they come to understand and interpret the world around them. The best documentary filmmakers have a firm point of view, but they also don't rely solely on facts to support the story they want to tell. They shift, whether subtly or radically, the foundations from which a spectator comes to understand an issue or topic. ftos_banner1 (more…)

Uncategorized

My Current Documentary Viewing List

As I wrap up my last documentary, Pride Denied, and am developing my next documentary on citizenship, I've decided to do an intensive review of art and experimental documentaries. On this list are films that I have seen and loved, as well as films I've yet to see (probably about a 50/50 split). I've tried to develop a list that is diverse in terms of subject matter, form, and ethnic/gender/sexual positionalities of the directors themselves. However, this list is far from exhaustive and could still use considerable expansion, so please feel free to make suggestions in the comments! I'll try to post reviews as I watch. [caption id="attachment_613" align="alignnone" width="745"]Trinh DVCAM4-4R Filmmaker Trinh. T. Minh-ha[/caption] (more…)

Uncategorized

Wedding or Prison? Rentboy.com and the Privatization of Queer and Trans Sex

One of the major problems with the push for same-sex marriage, as I wrote about in somewhat more detail before, is the complicity with the privatization of sex, which has been at the core of most of the so-called major gay "civil rights" advances since 2003 when the US Supreme Court overturned anti-sodomy laws in Lawrence v. Texas. Queer and trans sex, at least since the late-1800s, has been routinely conflated or associated with sex work both culturally and legally, and anti-sex work laws have in many places been used to target and criminalize queer and trans sex, both public and private. Toronto's 1981 police bathhouse raids are a great example, where almost 300 gay men were arrested by police and charged with either operating or being "found in" a "bawdy house," the Canadian legal term for "brothel." Today, trans women, especially trans women of color, are still routinely harassed and arrested by police for "looking like" a sex worker, simply for existing-while-trans. [caption id="attachment_487" align="alignleft" width="660"]Bathhouse raids protests, Toronto, February 1981. Bathhouse raids protests, Toronto, February 1981.[/caption] (more…)

Uncategorized

Why I Won’t Boycott STONEWALL (But Will Support Indie Queer & Trans Film)

I think many of my friends may be wondering why I haven't yet commented on or shared numerous articles condemning the new Stonewall (Roland Emmerich, 2015) film or calling for folks to boycott it that have circulated in the last few days since the release of the film's trailer. It's not because I'm incredibly busy finishing my own documentary about the whitewashing of LGBT politics, history, and pride events (though that is really what I should be doing right now instead of writing this). Nor is it because I don't have any thoughts or concerns about the film. It's because... wait for it... I haven't actually seen the film yet.¬† And neither have any of the people who have written criticisms about Stonewall or called for a boycott of it, as far as I can tell. (more…)

Uncategorized

The Limits of Identity: Rachel Dolezal and Andrea Smith

When news reports excoriating Rachel Dolezal's representation of herself as Black first surfaced (the question of her presentation of herself as Indigenous seems to have not sparked similar interest or concern), she was almost universally condemned. The NAACP, however, for whom Dolezal worked as the President of the Spokane chapter, released several statements of support for Dolezal, saying this upon her resignation: "The NAACP is not concerned with the racial identity of our leadership but the institutional integrity of our advocacy." But few seemed to share this position, or even ask what the value of Dolezal's work as an activist, scholar, or teacher may have been. My point here is not to undermine the outpouring of grief and anger regarding Dolezal or question the forms it took. Rather, I'm interested in the questions and stakes are emerging now that a much more well known scholar and activist, Andrea Smith, has become the subject of a somewhat similar scandal. Soon after the Dolezal story broke, a series of Tumblr posts, and a dedicated page, emerged under the heading "Andrea Smith Is Not Cherokee" (see Joanne Barker's blog for a detailed chronology and analysis. Here is a statement from the author of the original Tumblr post about her motivations for writing about Smith. A Tumblr archive dedicated to outlining the issues around Smith's representation of herself as Cherokee, and calls accountability around this, can be found here). (more…)

Uncategorized

All I Feel Right Now Is Shame: The High Cost of Marriage “Equality”

Two days ago, an undocumented Latina transwoman risked her own personal well-being to disrupt a self-congratulatory love fest between so-called LGBT leaders and Barack Obama, an event celebrating the "success" of the inclusion of some lesbian and gays into the fold of US citizenship.¬†Jennicet Gutierrez interrupted Obama's press conference, calling attention to the abuses of the US immigration detention system, including the disproportionate harms experienced by LGBTQ people caught up in the system. This was the response of Obama and the LGBT leaders in the room: [embed]https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=16&v=vv9wRNuptC8[/embed] (more…)